This week, we read Accessing Information Use by Humanists and Social Scientists: A Study at the Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina by Susana Romanos de Tiratel as well as Accidentally Found on Purpose: Information-Seeking Behavior of Historians in Archives by Wendy A. Duff and Catherine A. Johnson. As the name implies, the Tiratel article compares the habits of scholars of the humanities, humanists (Preference of books over journals, literature remains valid for 20 to 30 years, long shelf life of the studied sources), with the habits of social scientists (Equal preference for books and journals, average use validity of literature: nine years, intensive use of current material).
Accidentally Found describes a four stage process of familiarizing oneself with the archives, seeking material, building contextual knowledge, and identifying relevant material and the myriad of factors within. Archives can be unwieldy and an intimidating place at first, but assistance from an experienced individual can help relieve those feelings. Emphasis was placed in particular on the importance of proper context and how it is hard to understand what one is searching for without it.
Compared to some past articles, the articles were something of a success story. All the groups use the library as a source of information. Humanities scholars use the library a bit more and their needs appear to be easily met since their material is often relevant for decades and found in book form. Similar to historians, social scientists have slightly more complex needs than humanists, given that their reference materials are constantly being updated. There are still barriers and issues. Material is sometimes lost or misplaced, but a good librarian already does their best to keep their books and journals in good condition. However, there were complaints of serious difficulties in locating and obtaining material, a place where many librarians can improve upon. A librarian who constantly serves specific branches of the academic community should take the time to know where to find specific elements of that field beyond its place in the Dewey Decimal system. Other problems include lack of sufficient stock of books and journals, delays between request and reception of material, and excessively long home loans of material.
Wednesday, November 28, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment