This week’s reading came from Student Learning Through Ohio School Libraries, Part 1: How Effective School Libraries Help Students. The question of focus was how school libraries help students with their learning in and away from school and how effective school libraries play an active role. When I was in grade school, I was fortunate enough to have library be a weekly “special” much like art, music, or gym. Now, the library plays a more passive role in my district. Students only go when their teacher signs up. All of the pressure from No Child Left Behind to promote English and vocabulary skills has ironically cut significantly into time dedicated to reading, which promoted those skills. Students have the option to visit the library during their activity period, but only a select few actually do often because they have other activities like band or sports.
The second article we read this week was Situated Cognition and the Culture of Learning by John Seely Brown, Allan Collins and Paul Duguid. One of the important details in the Brown article is that concepts, like the definitions of words, are always under construction. It seems apparent that part of that may be due to another “evolving” concept we learned about, context. One of the conclusions of the article was the challenge of determining what should be made explicit in teaching and what should be left implicit. This is an issue faced by all sorts of information specialists, even if they do not realize it. One may initially believe that the more explicit information one has the better, but that is not the case. I found the emphasis on examples from the field of mathematics a bit startling. In this field I give little thought to mathematics in general. My emphasis is typically more on the humanities.
For the record, one answer to the magic box problem is:
8 1 6
3 5 7
4 9 2
Random note: on Heroes, Claire the cheerleader claims to be doing a paper about how libraries are becoming obsolete in the digital era. Ouch.
Tuesday, October 16, 2007
Monday, October 15, 2007
"This week’s topic was about context with regards to research and information seeking. To better understand this, we read Dervin’s “Given a context by any other name: Methodological tools for taming the unruly beast” and Talja’s “The production of ‘context’ in information seeking research: a metatheoretical view.” "
These papers serve as an introduction to understanding the range of factors that shape information needs, information seeking and use.
Rather than summarizing the papers separately, I would like you to complete the comparative table to build your key understandings.
These papers serve as an introduction to understanding the range of factors that shape information needs, information seeking and use.
Rather than summarizing the papers separately, I would like you to complete the comparative table to build your key understandings.
| Author | Dervin | Talja et al | |
| Definition of Context | Dervin does not explicitly define context the same way the other article does. This agrees with her belief that context is not an institution but rather an “in between”. | “Some kind of background for something the researcher wishes to understand and explain” Divides into the more common objectified context, which is presented and described, but not philosophically or theoretically. There is also interpreted context that is not understood as an independent entity but as a carrier of meaning. | |
| Key scholars theorizing about context | Dervin acknowledges that previous scholars often used one of three major approaches: textual analysis, systems theory, or the psychology of context. Like many Dervin articles, there are graphic interpretations. | Dervin Reneker believes researchers have failed to correctly identify the variables affecting information seeking and use Dewey Barry studied the use of electronic resources in theoretical physics. Silverman suggests human behavior as we know it is constructed from cultural meanings. | |
| Key assumptions made about context | 1. Knowledge is partial and temporary. 2. Reality is discontinuous, gap filled, changeable across time-space 3. The knower and the known are inextricably bound 4. Context is not usefully conceptualized as independent entity 5. Context requires a focus on process 6. Focus must be placed on the dialectical relationships between product and process 7. Focus must be placed on multiple interdependencies 8. Context is a necessary source of meaning. | ||
| Why research “context”? | Context is a popular issue, but polarizing opinions are actually hindering many scholars’ understanding of it, which seems to go against everything we’ve learned so far. | To gain a better understanding of how our interpretations change our perceptions. | |
| Key methodologies used to study “context” | Dervin takes a roundabout approach in order to “tease out” her own opinions regarding a topic she already considers chaotic at best. | Studying context is a very theoretical process using thorough examination of the situation from a behaviorist, social constructionist, and other perspectives. | |
| Key claims about “context” | Contextual factors are not understood as distinct, separate entities having different kinds of effects on the research object. Dervin devises a list of implications she has found and sums them up in one sentence: “I must learn—and, I believe we must all learn—to walk the in between”. Dervin concludes that we should be “accepting the inherent absolute unattainability of our quest while pursuing the journey”. | Context is usually produced in research by naming the entities that affect the object of research. According to objective approach, few things are real because they go through an interpretation. The interpretive approach says data represents social reality rather than simply describing it. Context is a key factor that ultimately defines reality relative to ourselves. |
Sunday, October 14, 2007
This week I read Inside the Search Process: Information Seeking from the User’s Perspective by Carol C. Kuhlthau. One of the concepts reinforced in the article was the importance of the user’s emotional state throughout the information search process. The Information Search Process has six stages: task initiation, selection, exploration, focus formulation, collection, and presentation. These stages can they be categorized into feelings, thoughts, and actions.
The article referred to multiple topics from past articles, such as sense making from the Dervin articles and the concept of affixing new knowledge into the user’s existing realm of knowledge. Better understanding these concepts enabled me to understand some elements of this article that would have been confusing a few weeks ago. I still have some doubts regarding the importance of the user’s emotional state and elements like invitational and indicative mood. However, I still see the value of understanding the evolution of thought and action throughout the information seeking practice. Ultimately, the Information Search Process chronicles the progression a typical user goes through when seeking new information.
I also read A Social Constructionist Approach to the Study of Information Use as Discursive Action by Kimmo Tuominen and Reijo Savolainen. To summarize, when we search for information, how we search and interpret it is often based on group dynamics. How we speak and write helps us to organize our social reality. In this approach, language is a form of social activity as well as a tool that organizes our thoughts.
Language is not just “a way to the means [in your head]” but language is an important part of that mean. You must look at the society and the cultural mores from which an individual comes in order to understand how they organize their thoughts and information. Discourse analysis attempts to neutralize speech, encouraging a speaker to assume “out-thereness”, the goal is to diminish bias and negate the cultural difference.
Social constructionist approach acknowledge society’s role in the study of information while discursive analysis works to negate and neutralize the bias. It recognizes that frequently a speaker shifts the authority from himself or herself onto an outlet or authority.
The article referred to multiple topics from past articles, such as sense making from the Dervin articles and the concept of affixing new knowledge into the user’s existing realm of knowledge. Better understanding these concepts enabled me to understand some elements of this article that would have been confusing a few weeks ago. I still have some doubts regarding the importance of the user’s emotional state and elements like invitational and indicative mood. However, I still see the value of understanding the evolution of thought and action throughout the information seeking practice. Ultimately, the Information Search Process chronicles the progression a typical user goes through when seeking new information.
I also read A Social Constructionist Approach to the Study of Information Use as Discursive Action by Kimmo Tuominen and Reijo Savolainen. To summarize, when we search for information, how we search and interpret it is often based on group dynamics. How we speak and write helps us to organize our social reality. In this approach, language is a form of social activity as well as a tool that organizes our thoughts.
Language is not just “a way to the means [in your head]” but language is an important part of that mean. You must look at the society and the cultural mores from which an individual comes in order to understand how they organize their thoughts and information. Discourse analysis attempts to neutralize speech, encouraging a speaker to assume “out-thereness”, the goal is to diminish bias and negate the cultural difference.
Social constructionist approach acknowledge society’s role in the study of information while discursive analysis works to negate and neutralize the bias. It recognizes that frequently a speaker shifts the authority from himself or herself onto an outlet or authority.
This week I read From the Mind’s Eye of the User: The Sense-Making Qualitative-Quantitative Methodology by Brenda Dervin. In the introduction, sense making is summarized as what users want from systems, what they get, and what they think about them. The sense-making metaphor is the triangle of situation, gap, and help that we first encountered in the Wilson article we read the first week.
While I was reading this, I began to compare the concerns presented in the article appear are user-oriented rather than system-oriented to some of the concepts we are studying in multimedia production. When designing web sites, the rule of thumb is to design in a postmodern fashion by being concise and designing with the user in mind rather than the author or site owner. In short, like libraries web sites are also taking a user-oriented approach rather than a system-oriented approach.
After reading From the Mind’s Eye of the User, I read ASQ: Alternative Tools for Information Need and Accountability Assessments by Libraries. I wish I had read them in the opposite order. After reading an article written in Dervin’s elaborate style, studying a series of short passages of information and almost childlike graphics felt almost surreal in its simplicity.
As we discussed in class, Dervin’s proposal of a sense-making model uses both internal behavior and external behaviors because just one isn’t going to give you the whole picture.
While I was reading this, I began to compare the concerns presented in the article appear are user-oriented rather than system-oriented to some of the concepts we are studying in multimedia production. When designing web sites, the rule of thumb is to design in a postmodern fashion by being concise and designing with the user in mind rather than the author or site owner. In short, like libraries web sites are also taking a user-oriented approach rather than a system-oriented approach.
After reading From the Mind’s Eye of the User, I read ASQ: Alternative Tools for Information Need and Accountability Assessments by Libraries. I wish I had read them in the opposite order. After reading an article written in Dervin’s elaborate style, studying a series of short passages of information and almost childlike graphics felt almost surreal in its simplicity.
As we discussed in class, Dervin’s proposal of a sense-making model uses both internal behavior and external behaviors because just one isn’t going to give you the whole picture.
This week’s assigned readings for class were Question-Negotiation and Information Seeking in Libraries by Robert S. Taylor and ASK for Information Retrieval: Part I by Belkin, Oddy, and Brooks. Question-Negotiation and Information Seeking in Libraries examined experiences and outcomes related to user user self-service and professional assistance as well as the factors attributed to both experiences. ASK for Information Retrieval: Part I discusses the history of the study of the ‘Anomalous State of Knowledge’ (ASK) and the THOMAS system as well as an integrated application of the project.
I was a little shocked that Question-Negotiation and Information Seeking in Libraries opened with the thought that libraries will ‘wither away’ and be replaced with an alternative if they do not evolve to meet the expectations of the user. However, given that there will always be a need for information and libraries have been changing drastically for years, I wonder if the two choices are really different. I also did not realize how far along in the process of acquiring knowledge libraries and research fall. According to the pre negotiation chart in Figure 1, there are three decisions that occur before one enters a library. However, as a sign of the times, I wonder how much more extensive average person’s “personal files” have become with the Internet and everything else as opposed to twenty years ago. However, I seriously question the five filters through which a question passes according to this article. Perhaps I still hold some traditional standards regarding information or maybe it’s something I do subconsciously without notice, but I find it extremely difficult to believe that a seeker’s objective and motivation as well as his or her personal characteristics play such a significant part in finding information. I agree that with regards to knowledge all of these factors are important, but I would like to define for myself by the end of the semester where an information specialist or librarian stands on the line between sharing information and shaping knowledge. I believe a librarian should help shape the knowledge of the young and inexperienced, but I feel that there are other cases where the experience falls primarily on the user.
Given that Information Behavior is a relatively new field of study, I was surprised that ASK for Information Retrieval: Part I was published in 1982, but as a result I see the roots of user-based information as opposed to the more traditional system-based behavior, which was being called dated even back then. The ASK hypothesis is an excellent example. The ASK hypothesis states that instead of identifying the user’s questions at face value, the professional is trying to identify the user’s lapse of knowledge. The user-oriented approach sounds more idealistic, but after our conversations in class about information and knowledge, I questioned the idea of an information specialist specifically confronting and shaping the knowledge of a patron. I also wonder if the THOMAS system has been updated since then. I feel as though the Internet and digital technology could help expand on its premise and make for an interesting system. After reading Part I of the Belkin article, I would like to read Part II. However, it does not appear to be one of our assigned readings. Perhaps I will explore this in my own time.
Like: Good analysis and questions in section on Taylor, especially interesting question about sharing information and shaping knowledge
Dislike: Section on Belkin is too focused on summary
I was a little shocked that Question-Negotiation and Information Seeking in Libraries opened with the thought that libraries will ‘wither away’ and be replaced with an alternative if they do not evolve to meet the expectations of the user. However, given that there will always be a need for information and libraries have been changing drastically for years, I wonder if the two choices are really different. I also did not realize how far along in the process of acquiring knowledge libraries and research fall. According to the pre negotiation chart in Figure 1, there are three decisions that occur before one enters a library. However, as a sign of the times, I wonder how much more extensive average person’s “personal files” have become with the Internet and everything else as opposed to twenty years ago. However, I seriously question the five filters through which a question passes according to this article. Perhaps I still hold some traditional standards regarding information or maybe it’s something I do subconsciously without notice, but I find it extremely difficult to believe that a seeker’s objective and motivation as well as his or her personal characteristics play such a significant part in finding information. I agree that with regards to knowledge all of these factors are important, but I would like to define for myself by the end of the semester where an information specialist or librarian stands on the line between sharing information and shaping knowledge. I believe a librarian should help shape the knowledge of the young and inexperienced, but I feel that there are other cases where the experience falls primarily on the user.
Given that Information Behavior is a relatively new field of study, I was surprised that ASK for Information Retrieval: Part I was published in 1982, but as a result I see the roots of user-based information as opposed to the more traditional system-based behavior, which was being called dated even back then. The ASK hypothesis is an excellent example. The ASK hypothesis states that instead of identifying the user’s questions at face value, the professional is trying to identify the user’s lapse of knowledge. The user-oriented approach sounds more idealistic, but after our conversations in class about information and knowledge, I questioned the idea of an information specialist specifically confronting and shaping the knowledge of a patron. I also wonder if the THOMAS system has been updated since then. I feel as though the Internet and digital technology could help expand on its premise and make for an interesting system. After reading Part I of the Belkin article, I would like to read Part II. However, it does not appear to be one of our assigned readings. Perhaps I will explore this in my own time.
Like: Good analysis and questions in section on Taylor, especially interesting question about sharing information and shaping knowledge
Dislike: Section on Belkin is too focused on summary
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
