These papers serve as an introduction to understanding the range of factors that shape information needs, information seeking and use.
Rather than summarizing the papers separately, I would like you to complete the comparative table to build your key understandings.
| Author | Dervin | Talja et al | |
| Definition of Context | Dervin does not explicitly define context the same way the other article does. This agrees with her belief that context is not an institution but rather an “in between”. | “Some kind of background for something the researcher wishes to understand and explain” Divides into the more common objectified context, which is presented and described, but not philosophically or theoretically. There is also interpreted context that is not understood as an independent entity but as a carrier of meaning. | |
| Key scholars theorizing about context | Dervin acknowledges that previous scholars often used one of three major approaches: textual analysis, systems theory, or the psychology of context. Like many Dervin articles, there are graphic interpretations. | Dervin Reneker believes researchers have failed to correctly identify the variables affecting information seeking and use Dewey Barry studied the use of electronic resources in theoretical physics. Silverman suggests human behavior as we know it is constructed from cultural meanings. | |
| Key assumptions made about context | 1. Knowledge is partial and temporary. 2. Reality is discontinuous, gap filled, changeable across time-space 3. The knower and the known are inextricably bound 4. Context is not usefully conceptualized as independent entity 5. Context requires a focus on process 6. Focus must be placed on the dialectical relationships between product and process 7. Focus must be placed on multiple interdependencies 8. Context is a necessary source of meaning. | ||
| Why research “context”? | Context is a popular issue, but polarizing opinions are actually hindering many scholars’ understanding of it, which seems to go against everything we’ve learned so far. | To gain a better understanding of how our interpretations change our perceptions. | |
| Key methodologies used to study “context” | Dervin takes a roundabout approach in order to “tease out” her own opinions regarding a topic she already considers chaotic at best. | Studying context is a very theoretical process using thorough examination of the situation from a behaviorist, social constructionist, and other perspectives. | |
| Key claims about “context” | Contextual factors are not understood as distinct, separate entities having different kinds of effects on the research object. Dervin devises a list of implications she has found and sums them up in one sentence: “I must learn—and, I believe we must all learn—to walk the in between”. Dervin concludes that we should be “accepting the inherent absolute unattainability of our quest while pursuing the journey”. | Context is usually produced in research by naming the entities that affect the object of research. According to objective approach, few things are real because they go through an interpretation. The interpretive approach says data represents social reality rather than simply describing it. Context is a key factor that ultimately defines reality relative to ourselves. |

No comments:
Post a Comment